Book Review: “A Fate So Cold” by Amanda Foody and C.L. Herman

People have strong feelings about tropes, but one thing I love is flipping tropes on their head. That’s what we’re getting in Amanda Foody and C.L. Herman’s latest novel together, A Fate So Cold.

A Fate So Cold [Buy Bookshop Amazon LibroFM] is a dual POV story following Dominic and Ellery. They are both training to weild magic and bond with a living wand. Dominic doesn’t expect much, but somehow ends up bonding with the strongest summer wand, meanwhile Ellery accidentally creates a winter wand. It comes when their land, which is ruled by summer, facing a threat from winter, and instead of a Chose One, they believe the prophecy marked them as the Chosen Two.

Or…. are they? This is a fun twist on the Chosen One trope, as well as flipping enemies to lovers into a friends to lovers to enemies situation.

I really enjoyed Amanda and C.L.’s writing style. They used some lovely turns of phrase and decriptions. They also have some fun dialogue, which apparently comes from role playing scenes together to craft those conversations. Their co-writing process is unique and sounds pretty fun.

I read this book half by eyeball and half by audio, and I was much more locked in with eyeball reading than listening. I don’t know if that was due to narration or the story itself, but I’m leaning toward the former, as the ending is just the midpoint of this story. Book two is expected in the fall of 2026 and I’m eager to see who wins this battle and how Dominic and Ellery work their way out of this situation.

117. K.L. WALTHER: A Risky Business retelling, romcom shenanigans, and heavy topics in YA romance LiteraryHype Podcast

Send us Fan MailThis week on LiteraryHype Podcast, K.L. Walther joins me to talk about her two upcoming books, We're A Bad Idea, Right? and The Summer of Second Chances. These two YA romcoms are set in the same world, but are coming out from separate publishers. We're talking all about the challenges of publishing with two teams, creating the perfect shenanigans for a YA romcom, and tackling hard topics for teens, including a grandparent with dementia.FOLLOW KLBUY THE BOOKSBookshop:We're A Bad Idea, RIght?The Summer Of Second ChancesAmazon:We're A Bad Idea, RIght?The Summer Of Second ChancesLibroFM:  We're A Bad Idea, RIght?The Summer Of Second ChancesSupport the showSupport the podcast by shopping:EtsyMy Bookshop.org listsLibroFM audiobooksTry Audible Plus  Gift Audible Membership Glocusent LED Neck Reading LightTry Shameless Snacks10% Off at Once Upon a Bookclub10% off Goli VitaminsTWO FREE AUDIOBOOKS with new LibroFM Membership: Kindle Unlimited FREE FOR THREE MONTHS!Prime Television FREE TRIALJoin the fun!WebsiteInstagramTiktokY…

Leave a comment